The Leadership Catalyst is where municipal power and women’s leadership collide. I expose how staff culture builds or breaks public trust, and why women leaders must set the standard for their teams and their communities. This is unapologetic strategy, rooted in SCALE™, for leaders who refuse to carry the weight of broken systems alone. Subscribe and join a community that’s rewriting the rules of government leadership.
Share
Issue 45: You Have Been Doing This Alone and It Is Costing You More Than You Know | The Record™ Series | Issue 5 of 5
Published 28 days ago • 4 min read
Dear Reader,
Over the past four issues I have walked you through building your narrative anchors, documenting your impact, naming your community witnesses, and protecting your longevity inside the seat.
Today I am closing the series with the component most women never think to build.
Not a document. Not a strategy. A relationship.
The private advisory relationship the role demands and the system never built for you.
The Catalyst Perspective
I want to tell you about a woman who changed what was possible for me inside the seat.
She was a former mayor of a major Midwest city who gave years of her leadership to her community. After her time in office she continued the work, consulting for Cities United and the National League of Cities (NLC), building more equitable and safer communities across the country. She connected me to the Cities United network because I had been honest with her about the violence happening in my hometown. That connection changed the trajectory of my leadership.
But that is not the part of the story that belongs here.
She was leading an NLC mayors cohort. I was one of six mayors in that cohort with her. I was carrying what women in executive public leadership carry. The way your decisiveness gets read as aggression while a man doing the same thing gets called a strong leader. The way your competence gets questioned in rooms where his is simply assumed.
I arrived in that seat with a master's degree, two congressional staffing appointments, years of community board service, and two terms on city council. My competence was still questioned, particularly by people who would never have applied that standard to a man with half my preparation.
That is not unique to me.
The Under Pressure report found that women mayors face disproportionate scrutiny of their competence at statistically significant rates. Men with no college degrees run for public office and their qualifications are rarely questioned. Women arrive overqualified and still spend energy proving something their male counterparts are simply given. The report also found that women's ability to serve is questioned on the basis of their family roles, as mothers and as wives, in ways that are never applied to men. (Midthun and Spear, Mayors Innovation Project, University of Wisconsin-Madison, September 2025.)
We were in that cohort before the research existed to name any of it. We were simply women in seats, comparing notes, and slowly recognizing that what each of us had been carrying alone was not a personal failing.
It was a pattern.
Photo Credit: National League of Cities
One evening during our time together, she pulled me aside. This woman who had held a seat like mine, who had no position to protect inside my political situation, looked at me and said four words. "You are not crazy." Years later we both contributed to the research that documented in data what she named for me at that moment. We stay in close contact at least monthly. At every Mayors Innovation Project conference we are intentional about spending real time together.
A walk. A Starbucks run. A shared meal. Not a meeting. Time. The kind that sustains a relationship across years and across the distance of separate lives.
She has been a rock for several mayors who came behind her. Not because it was her job. Because she chose to be the person she needed when she was in the seat.
That is what Component 5 of The Record™ is built on.
The SCALE™ Framework Connection
S — Strengths-Based Leadership™ When the pressure of the seat makes your strengths invisible to you, the private advisor who has no position to protect reflects your record back to you with precision when the room has stopped seeing it and when you have stopped seeing it yourself.
C — Confidence and Cognitive Reframing™ When your competence is questioned despite your credentials and your family role is used to diminish your authority, your relationship to your own record is what holds you steady. The private advisor helps you separate what is political from what is personal so you can lead from a grounded place rather than a reactive one.
A — Aligned Values and Boundary Negotiation™ The role will test your values in ways no job description names. The private advisor does not tell you what to decide. She helps you hear yourself clearly enough to make the decision that belongs entirely to you and aligns with the leader you have spent years becoming.
L — Leadership Longevity™ The women who hold up longest are not the ones who absorbed the most pressure. They are the ones who built the private infrastructure to sustain themselves before the role depleted what they arrived with. Private advisory support is not something you add when things get hard. It is the investment you make before the hard season arrives.
E — Emboldened Ecosystem Building™ Your professional network is irreplaceable and it was never designed to hold what the seat itself generates. The private advisor exists outside your ecosystem with no stake in your political outcome and no position to protect while sitting with you in yours. That is not a critique of your network. It is the most honest description of why this relationship requires its own category entirely.
Photo Credit: Mayors Innovation Project
The SCALE™ Framework in Action: Take Action
This week I want you to sit with one question.
Who is the person in your life right now who has held a seat like yours, has no position to protect inside your current situation, and can tell you the truth about what you are navigating?
If you have that person, invest in that relationship. Be as intentional about protecting that time as you are about protecting everything else on your calendar. That relationship is not a luxury. It is the infrastructure the role requires.
If you do not have that person yet, name that honestly. The cost is already showing up somewhere in your leadership, in the decisions you second-guess too long, in the weight you carry home that does not belong there, in the version of yourself you protect in public because there is nowhere private to set it down.
You do not have to keep doing this alone.
The Closing of The Record™
Five issues. Five components. One framework built entirely from the inside of the seats I have held.
Component 5 gives you the relationship that makes all four of the others work. It is the private space where you can think out loud without protecting anyone in the room. It is the voice that has been where you are going. It is the relationship that holds you accountable to your own record when the pressure makes that record hard to see.
If something in this series named what you have been carrying, reply to this email and tell me where you are right now. I read every response and I reply to every one.
Leadership Strategist for Municipal Teams Former Mayor | Village Manager | City Councilor | Congressional Staffer Creator of the SCALE™ Framework for Public Sector Leadership
The Leadership Catalyst is where municipal power and women’s leadership collide. I expose how staff culture builds or breaks public trust, and why women leaders must set the standard for their teams and their communities. This is unapologetic strategy, rooted in SCALE™, for leaders who refuse to carry the weight of broken systems alone. Subscribe and join a community that’s rewriting the rules of government leadership.
Dear Reader, Your Record Was Never the Problem. The Catalyst Perspective For the past several months, I have been building real connections with women in local government leadership across LinkedIn. I did not expect how much these conversations would move me. A woman wrote to me about a city manager seat she had earned and was doing well in, until a new mayor came in who did not trust her. The emails started arriving late at night. The scrutiny had nothing to do with her performance and...
Dear Reader, In Issue 43 I told you about the Community Foundation and the moment their words became testimony rather than advocacy. What I did not tell you is what happened after the meetings ended. What happened when I walked through the door and my husband could tell from the way I closed it what kind of night it had been. Nobody warned me about that part. The Catalyst Perspective I served as mayor of a city with 14 council members. Approximately half had been aligned with the previous...
Dear Reader, In Issue 42 I told you about the day I stopped explaining myself. I told you the documentation was already older than the attack. I told you the people who wanted to understand already understood and the people who did not never would. What I did not tell you is what made it possible to trust the record enough to stop. It was not the paperwork. It was the people who watched me build it. The Catalyst Perspective When I decided to create the Mayor Chasity Wells-Armstrong...